Will the charms cripple and numb work on creatures that are immune to paralyze?

Question

Can someone clarify the charms Cripple and Numb on how it will work on a creature. I'm confused because the official forum says one thing then tibia fandom says another. I don't know if it's because there was changes or if this is two different questions? Is a monster being immune to a paralyze rune different than a monster being immune to paralyze? My head hurts but ultimately I want to know if you can use these charms on a creature if their immune to paralyze.

> Cripple and Numb: Stupid question but, if creatures are immune to paralysis this won't work at all, right?
That's correct.

Source: https://www.tibia.com/forum/?action=thread&postid=38085287#post38085287

For Cripple and Numb on Tibia Fandom:

This affects creatures even if they are immune to the Paralyse Rune.

Source: https://tibia.fandom.com/wiki/Cripple

Comments

Excellent question. This kind of stuff really confuses even experienced players.

Answer 1

It does work even in creatures immune to paralyze.

For example, I have seen RPs using in on Roshamul bridge against Frazzlemaws, which are immune to the paralyze rune, but it works on them

In this video you can see you Numb affects the dragons, and it is immune to paralyze too:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEVSBtmZ0no