Why is Dawnfire Asura a Hard (2500 kills) creature and Midnight Asura a Medium (1000 kills) creature?

Question

	Dawnfire Asura	Midnight Asura
HP	2900	3100
XP	3610	3700

Midnight Asura has more HP and XP, and also deals more damage in my experience. Why is it Medium while Dawnfire is Hard?

Answer 1

   Hello!
   Yes, it's really quite strange. Researching further, I saw that this question had already been answered on Tibia forum by a CM, and he said he also didn't know how to explain it.
    Taking into account that bestiaries are defined in categories automatically based on exp, life and also damage, it is possible to deduce that dawnfire asura is probably stronger than midnight asura, and it is possible to check this if you have the patience to keep tanking 1 of each for some time and then analyze the input analyzer
   Finally, in my opinion, it's just a bug, and because they are two creatures in the same spawn, with a very similar appearance rate, they didn't bother to fix it because it didn't make much of a difference.

Comments

Thanks for your research! Would you mind sharing the link to the CM response in the official forums (adding it to your reply)?

---

Unfortunately, I can't since the forum post is over 6 years old and probably doesn't even exist anymore. The only records we have of the CM's response are old Reddit posts about it ( here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TibiaMMO/comments/9vtblt/why_does_midnight_and_frost_flower_asura_need/?rdt=55363 ).

---

Thanks for the link!